Interpreting overlap statistics

There are two alternative hypotheses in overlap statistics, either boundary association or boundary avoidance. For two sets of boundaries, G and H, boundaries that overlap would have high values of OS and low values of OG, OH, and OGH. Low values of OS and high values of OG, OH, and OGH indicate boundary avoidance.

The table below provides a quick reference:

Statistic

Meaning

Overlap

Avoidance

OS

the number of Boundary Elements (BEs) in both sets of boundaries

high (upper tail significant)

low (lower tail significant)

OG

directional overlap, association of G with H

low

high

OH

directional overlap, association of H with G

low

high

OGH

simultaneous overlap, association between the boundaries

low

high

You can use Monte Carlo randomization to determine whether the observed value of a test statistic is either significantly high or significantly low. BoundarySeer will present the p-values for the upper and lower tails of the Monte Carlo distribution. Use the table above to determine which tail to evaluate for which alternative hypothesis. To evaluate whether a test statistic is unusually low, examine the lower tail p-value (from the lower end of the distribution). To evaluate whether a test statistic is unusually high, examine the upper tail p-value (from the upper end of the distribution). (See also: Calculating Monte Carlo p-values)

Simulation studies (Jacquez 1995) demonstrated that the significance of OS is related to the presence of large-scale boundaries (boundaries whose lengths are on the same scale as sampling), even when H is dependent on G. OG is significant when boundaries for G are nearer to boundaries for H than expected, and a similar interpretation follows for OH. OGH measures the simultaneous fit between the two boundary sets.

Note

BE CAREFUL interpreting OS, because there are many situations where the spatial support for the two boundaries preclude any direct overlap. If this happens, OS will always be zero, and it should not be included in the analysis.

See also:

Examples: